January 1917Berlin, London, Washington, Mexico City
The Zimmermann telegram
1 The story
On 16 January 1917 the German foreign minister, Arthur Zimmermann, sent a telegram in code to his ambassador in Washington, to be passed on to Mexico. Germany was about to start unrestricted submarine warfare on 1 February. If that brought the United States into the war, Mexico was to be offered an alliance, money, and the chance to win back Texas, New Mexico and Arizona. Britain had cut Germany’s own Atlantic cables at the start of the war, so the telegram went over other countries’ lines, including American diplomatic cables that passed through Britain. There the codebreakers of the British Admiralty, known as Room 40, read it.
We intend to begin on the first of February unrestricted submarine warfare. We shall endeavor in spite of this to keep the United States of America neutral. In the event of this not succeeding, we make Mexico a proposal or alliance on the following basis: make war together, make peace together, generous financial support and an understanding on our part that Mexico is to reconquer the lost territory in Texas, New Mexico, and Arizona.
Read more
Room 40 was run by William Reginald Hall, the Director of Naval Intelligence. The team that read the telegram included Nigel de Grey; his own account of the work, written in 1945, is in The National Archives.
Hall had a problem. Showing the telegram to the Americans would tell them that Britain read their diplomatic cables, and would tell Germany that its code was broken. So he had a copy obtained in Mexico City, from the telegraph office there: the version that the German embassy in Washington had forwarded to Mexico, in another code, numbered 13040. Now the story could be that it had been found in Mexico.
On 24 February the American ambassador in London, Walter Page, cabled the text to Washington. It was in American newspapers on 1 March. Many said it was a British forgery, until Zimmermann himself admitted that it was genuine. The United States declared war on Germany on 6 April 1917.
2 The machine
The telegram was not in a cipher but in a code: a book that gives every word its own number group. Our book is made up, and in alphabetical order, so a word’s group grows with its place in the alphabet. Type some words and see their groups.
3 Your turn
Here is the start of the telegram, in the English of the decode above, in a codebook of the same kind as ours but with other numbers. Most of the book is already known; ten words are missing. Use what the telegram must be saying, and the alphabetical order of the book: a missing group between “territory” and “that” must be a word between them in the dictionary. Type each missing word into its box.
Cracked · in your notebook
Stuck?
- The plan concerns three American states that Mexico had lost. They are listed together near the end.
- Group 36357 comes between event (35448) and financial (36763), so its word starts with f and comes before fi. It is a month.
- The missing words are: february, submarine, america, neutral, mexico, alliance, together, peace, texas, arizona.
4 What really happened
The code. German diplomats used codebooks of numbered words and phrases. A codebook can be rebuilt without ever capturing it: from many intercepted messages, a guessed word here, a group that keeps coming back there, and the context. Room 40 read the telegram, and the copy from Mexico, in code 13040, let Britain pass the text to the Americans without revealing where it really came from. The National Archives in London still hold that codebook.
What followed. Wilson asked Congress for war on 2 April 1917. The historian David Kahn wrote of the telegram: “No other single cryptanalysis has had such enormous consequences.”
About the puzzle. The real telegram was in German, in German codes. Our codebook and its numbers are made up; the words are those of the State Department’s English decode, with one slip (“or” for “of”) put right.
Then and now: a codebook is a substitution of whole words. The Toolbox’s keyword substitution does the same with letters.
Sources
- National Archives (USA), “The Zimmermann Telegram”, milestone documents: the telegram as received (ID 302025), the decode (ID 302024) and its transcript. archives.gov
- National Archives (USA), Prologue, Winter 2016, “The Zimmermann Telegram”. archives.gov
- GCHQ, “A century on: how GCHQ’s predecessors contributed to the US entering World War I”. gchq.gov.uk
- UK Government history blog, “The Zimmermann telegram and Room 40”, 16 January 2017. history.blog.gov.uk
- “The Zimmermann Telegram”, Cryptologic Quarterly, NSA (with a translation of the German investigation report of April 1917). media.defense.gov
- J. Ehrman, review of T. Boghardt, The Zimmermann Telegram (Naval Institute Press, 2012), Studies in Intelligence 57(2), CIA, 2013. cia.gov
- The National Archives (UK), HW 3/176, German code book 13040, and HW 3/177, Nigel de Grey’s account of his work on the telegram (catalogue entries). discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk